Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places
Ian's Pizza is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

1. Ian's Pizza

8.2
2035 E North Ave (btw Farwell & Prospect), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 110 consigli e recensioni

Stephen M.Stephen Minutolo: Crazy awesome Mac n cheese slices

Tazinos is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

2. Tazinos

N56 W15560 Silver Spring Dr, Menomonee Falls, WI
Pizzeria · 20 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: For an all you can eat buffet this is pretty good. Buffalo chicken pizza and mac and cheese is always a good combination.

Classic Slice is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

3. Classic Slice

8.7
2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave (at S California St), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Bay View · 74 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: It's all about the Shipee Ahoy

4. Mellow Mushroom

8.5
1571 21st Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC
Pizzeria · 73 consigli e recensioni

Kate L.Kate Lynch: Try the Buffalo Chicken Pizza it is awesome!

Bianchis Pizza Downtown is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

5. Bianchis Pizza Downtown

7.5
607 La Salle St (at W. Main St.), Ottawa, IL
Pizzeria · 16 consigli e recensioni

Monica C.Monica Coleman: If you like hot sauce, it's a must here! And Hawaiian style is the bomb diggity.

Pietro's Pizza is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

6. Pietro's Pizza

7.6
2912 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Bay View · 3 consigli e recensioni

7. Balistreri Brothers Pizza

2952 S 13th St (Oklahoma Ave.), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · 2 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: All of their pizza is great, but there is something about their plain, cheese pizza that makes me order it every time. A must get. Also the best jalepeno poppers I've ever eaten!

8. Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante

8.7
812 N 68th St (Wells St), Milwaukee, WI
Ristorante italiano · 46 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: I usually like a lot of toppings on my pizza, but their plain, sausage pizza is the best.

Pizza Planet is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

9. Pizza Planet

Streets of America, Disney's Hollywood Studios (Walt Disney World), Lake Buena Vista, FL
Pizzeria · 122 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: Pizza's not the greatest, but I come here for the aliens from Toy Story. Who doesn't love em.

Pizza Pub is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

10. Pizza Pub

7.4
1455 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy (btwn Highway 13 & Pilgrim Dr), Wisconsin Dells, WI
Pizzeria · 59 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: Love how big the sausage pieces are. A must have every Dells trip.

Bel Gustos is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

11. Bel Gustos

3648 S Moorland Rd, New Berlin, WI
Pizzeria · 5 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: Very good thin crust pizza. Hawaiian is the best. Nice, dense layer of cheese.

Pizza Lucé is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

12. Pizza Lucé

8.7
119 N. Fourth St. (2nd Ave. N), Minneapolis, MN
Pizzeria · Warehouse District · 126 consigli e recensioni
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Brookfield is one of Puerto's Picks for Pizza Places.

13. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Brookfield

8.2
13175 W Bluemound Rd, Brookfield, WI
Pizzeria · 10 consigli e recensioni

Joe M.Joe M.: Chicken Parmesan pizza is the best!